Vintage G1 My Little Pony Applejack Long Hair Earth Hasbro MLP
C $35.59
Newly Listed
See all
Vintage G1 My Little Pony NSS Cherries Jubilee Earth Hasbro MLP
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Twice as Fancy Scoops Hasbro MLP TAF
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Rainbow Windy Unicorn Hasbro MLP
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony NSS Heart Throb Pegasus Hasbro MLP
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Twice as Fancy Up Up & Away Hasbro MLP
C $27.37
All items
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Rainbow Windy Unicorn Hasbro MLP
C $27.37
G3 My Little Pony Applejack Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Daisy May Pegasus Odor Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Jangles & Tangles Newborn Twin Hasbro MLP Set
C $35.59
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Carrying Case 6 Stall Hasbro MLP 1983
C $35.59
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Accessory Silver Metallic Ribbon Flutter Hasbro MLP
C $21.89
G3 My Little Pony Cherry Blossom II with Accessories Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Rarity I Unicorn Super Long Hair Hasbro MLP Rare HTF SLH
C $27.37
G3 My Little Pony Morning Dawn Delight Easter Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Silly Lily Breezie with Cart Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Twinkle Eye Gingerbread Hasbro MLP TE
C $35.59
G3 My Little Pony Honeydew Hum Breezie with Cart Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
G1 Style Anniversary My Little Pony Rainbow Pegasus Scented Basic Fun
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Sunshine Seaflower TLC Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $60.23
G3 My Little Pony Candy Apple TRU Exclusive 4-Pack Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $27.37
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Twilight Unicorn Light Pink Variant Hasbro MLP
C $35.59
Grateful Dead Bear Beanbag Plush Delilah 7" Beanie Liquid Blue with Tags
C $24.63
G3 My Little Pony Blushie Cutie Cascade Hasbro MLP Rare HTF Crystal Princess
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Cotton Candy II with Brush Toys R Us 4 Pack Hasbro MLP
C $19.16
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Newborn Twin Jebber Baby Hasbro MLP
C $21.89
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Doodles & Noodles Newborn Twins Hasbro MLP Set
C $35.59
G3 My Little Pony Pinkie Pie V 3D Symbol Hasbro MLP Rare HTF Favorite Friends
C $27.37
G3 My Little Pony Zipzee Breezie with Cart Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Blossom Earth Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $21.89
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Rainbow Sunlight Earth Hasbro MLP
C $21.89
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Twinkle Eye Tic Tac Toe Hasbro MLP Rare HTF TE
C $68.45
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Twice as Fancy Milky Way Unicorn Hasbro MLP TAF
C $35.59
G3 My Little Pony Twilight Twinkle Jewel Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Finger Paints Odor TRU 4-Pack Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $35.59
G3 My Little Pony Baby Romperooni Odor Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $16.42
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Surprise Pegasus Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $16.42
G3 My Little Pony Doseydotes with Hat Easter Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $21.89
G3 My Little Pony Razzaroo Birthday Celebration Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Alphabet Euro Exclusive TLC Hasbro MLP
C $35.59
Grateful Dead Bear Beanbag Plush Cosmic Charlie 7" Beanie Liquid Blue
C $13.68
G3 My Little Pony Princess Peppermint Odor Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Accessory Pink Floral Nightgown Twins Hasbro MLP Rare
C $16.42
Grateful Dead Bear Beanbag Plush Samson 7" Beanie Liquid Blue with Tags
C $16.42
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Little Honey Pie Teeny Tiny Baby Hasbro MLP
C $27.37
G3 My Little Pony Secret Wish Divine Shine Glitter Hasbro MLP
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Rainbow Swirl I Sparkle Glitter Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
G3 My Little Pony Rarity II 3D Symbol Hasbro MLP Rare HTF Favorite Friends
C $35.59
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Accessory Orange Glittery Star Pick Twinkler Hasbro
C $35.59
Vintage G1 My Little Pony SS Scrumptious NM Near Mint Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $68.45
Squishmallows Alizeh Red Fox 14" with Tags Kellytoy Plush
C $41.06
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Petite Prancing Pretty Carousel Playset Hasbro MLP
C $88.99
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Glory Unicorn Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $19.16
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Powder Unicorn Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
C $35.59
About us
My Little Ponies for sale & other vintage 1980's toys, games, and plush. G1 G2 G3 My Little Pony toys for sale. Buy Strawberry Shortcake, Care Bears, Cabbage Patch Kids, & lots more of your favorite toys from your childhood here!
Seller feedback (4,301)
3***d (60)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Item as described, price and shipping reasonable and received timely. Would buy here again
a***g (1306)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Smooth transaction, speedy delivery, safe packaging, fair pricing, great stuff!
p***_ (348)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Great seller, pony came quick and as described, I hope I can restore her for display.
5***i (82)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Sorry for delayed feedback, have had a sick dog here. Fast seller, accurate description, fast shipping, great price. Lovely Ebayer!! A+++++++++
l***l (131)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
My item arrived in lovely condition, safely packaged, and identical to its photos! Thank you so so much!😊
l***l (131)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
My item arrived in lovely condition, safely packaged, and identical to its photos! Thank you so so much!😊